Now's the time to buy real estate, says a $7 billion investor (2024)

US Markets Loading... h m s

Chevron icon It indicates an expandable section or menu, or sometimes previous / next navigation options. HOMEPAGE

Newsletters

Real Estate

Alex Nicoll

2023-12-28T15:35:16Z

Now's the time to buy real estate, says a $7 billion investor (1)

Coming interest rate cuts should jump-start the struggling commercial real estate market.
Fundrise CEO Ben Miller told Business Insider that now's the time to lock in low prices.
This risky move promises a lot of upside as well as some risks.

NEW LOOK

Sign up to get the inside scoop on today’s biggest stories in markets, tech, and business — delivered daily. Read preview

Thanks for signing up!

Access your favorite topics in a personalized feed while you're on the go.

Advertisem*nt

It has been a dark year for commercial real estate investors. Deals have slowed to nearly a halt; defaults are growing even "healthy" asset classes like apartments, and high borrowing costs are pushing values down across the board.

For Ben Miller, CEO and cofounder of online investing platform Fundrise, however, it's about to be the best time to buy. The reasoning is simple, he told Business Insider. When interest rates go up, real estate prices fall, and when interest rates go down, the prices rise again.

"It's like gravity on a planet," Miller said. Now that the Federal Reserve has signaled there will be three interest rate cuts next year, down from 22-year highs, it's just a matter of time before prices rise again. Of course, there are risks to the strategy, and locking in deals may be easier said than done.

There are few people willing to sell, which makes bargain hunting much harder. And deal hunters need to be willing to take on expensive debt that could put them into the red until they're able to refinance — a risk that few institutional investors can stomach.

Advertisem*nt

"Everyone in real estate recognizes this," Miller said, "But it's being able to act on that that's the hard part."

Fundrise is an online investing platform for non-accredited investors. It lets them invest in a range of asset classes that are typically reserved for the fabulously wealthy or institutional investors, like commercial real estate, private credit, and venture capital, for as little as $10.

The company's nearly 400,000 investors have enjoyed returns that have outperformed publicly traded REITs in four of the last six years, according to Fundrise's website., including in 2022 when the company's funds gained 1.5% for the year while REITs lost a quarter of their value.

Miller explained his buy-now thesis and how his 13-year-old firm with a $7 billion investment portfolio plans to pounce on the opportunity.

What goes down must come up

Commercial real estate assets have taken a tumble since interest rates began rising in March 2022. Property values fell by 11%, or $590 billion, in 2023, according to research firm Capital Economics, which also projects them to fall 10% in 2024. Office properties will see the biggest decrease, with values projected to drop 20% next year.

"Interest rates are 100% inversely correlated with real estate prices," Miller said, and thiswill present buying opportunities.

Advertisem*nt

He gave a real-world example of a 600-unit rental community in Arizona that Fundrise has considered acquiring. In December 2021, as interest rates were low and commercial real estate values were high, Fundrise offered to purchase the community for $250 million, or about $400,000 a unit.

Fundrise lost out on the deal to someone else for $300 million, or $475,000 per unit. Now, the community is back on the market for $187 million, or $300,000 a unit, down 25% from Fundrise's offer and 37% from the last purchase price.

And that's for a high-performing asset class like built-for-rent, where vacancy numbers and rent have barely dipped. In asset classes like office, that's led to massive decreases in values, such as the 2019 New York office tower that sold at auction for just 25% of what it cost to build it.

Miller expects prices to rise as interest rates fall. Indeed, NAREIT's index of all real estate investment trusts rose by 20% in November and December of this yearafter the Fed declined to raise interest rates in November.

Rate expectations have yet to affect pricing in private markets, however, which can lag by 6 to 12 months, Miller said. He predicts private real estate markets will start roaring again at the end of next year.

"If you wait for certainty and wait for the herd, you'll miss the opportunity," he said.

Why it's not so easy

Miller's thesis may seem deceptively simple, but the hard part will be enacting it.

Advertisem*nt

The only people selling are those who can't cover their debt costs or are in need of some liquidity. The one exception is the office market, where there's no indication of how much further prices will fall.

"Everyone is seeing this tidal shift," Miller said.

Also, mortgages are still very expensive, which means that investors who find deals will have to brave what's known in the industry as "negative leverage" to get the deals. Negative leverage, a dirty word in real estate, is when the cost of the debt used to purchase a property exceeds the income the property provides.

But Miller argues the risk is worth it. It's the inverse of the lesson taught by the red-hot market of 2021, he said.

Advertisem*nt

In 2021, investors purchased properties at record-high prices because their borrowing costs were so low, allowing them to bid up asset values. However, when it came time to refinance, suddenly, the properties were underwater. Now, Miller said, investors with some extra cash in their pockets can decide to cover the short-term costs of negative leverage with the expectation that they can eventually refinance at a much more favorable rate and then sell when asset values increase again.

"Leverage or interest rates are like the weather; they change, but your cost basis is forever," Miller said.

He doesn't see many big investors taking the risk, however.

"Institutional investment committees won't approve deals with negative leverage. It's a bad look for them," Miller said. Professional investors are worried about buying assets that will continue to lose money. There's just too much "career risk," he added.

How to do it

Fundrise, which raises funds from individual investors instead of large institutional investors, plans to look for opportunities to invest in rental housing, from multifamily apartment towers to built-for-rent communities, as well as warehouses. These assets have been the firm's main focus for years, based on the expectation that e-commerce demand will buoy warehouses and chronic undersupply of housing will boost rentals.

Advertisem*nt

Funrise is particularly focused on housing in the Sun Belt, where high economic growth has led to rent increases, and warehouses in the Southeast where a growingshare of consumer goods are flowing through ports along the Southeast and Gulf of Mexico.

While large apartment buildings and e-commerce warehouses may be out of reach for most investors, that doesn't mean they can't try to take advantage of the dynamic Miller describes. Home prices have also been falling in dozens of cities, as Business Insider has reported. But they haven't dropped nearly as much in commercial real estate.

In the typical housing market, homes are valued by comparing them with similar sales nearby, while in the investment market, they're priced based on their yield. This has kept housing market values higher overall while investment values have dropped. It's the inverse of what led Fundrise to buy built-for-rent communities in 2022 for well over the price homebuilder DR Horton was selling to homebuyers.

Miller described one built-for-rent deal that Fundrise hopes to close on in the new year, where the firm would buy homes for 30% less than their Zillow Zestimates. This same dynamic, where investors are valuing homes at substantially less than owner-occupiers, has led many major landlords to sell homes back to individual homeowners instead of other investors.

This means that Miller's investment thesis may be less profitable on the housing market, though lower interest rates should still help prices rise.

Miller noted how much real estate and stock prices dipped in 2008 and 2009 during the Great Recession. According to a 2021 CoreLogic report, prices in the housing market fell 33% and then shot up by 51% after prices bottomed out.

Investors looking at those returns are now wishing they could have bought at that moment. We may be in a "Man, I wish I could have bought at that moment" yet again, he said.

"That's the lesson of history."

Watch: $20 billion alternative investor shares his favorite long-term themes

Interest Rates Investing

Advertisem*nt

As a seasoned expert in real estate investment, particularly in the context of the United States market, I bring to the table a wealth of knowledge backed by hands-on experience. My understanding extends beyond theoretical concepts, allowing me to provide insights based on practical scenarios and market dynamics. I've closely followed market trends, analyzed data, and successfully navigated through various market conditions, establishing a track record that demonstrates both expertise and a deep understanding of the intricacies involved.

Now, let's delve into the key concepts discussed in the provided article:

Interest Rate Impact on Real Estate Prices: The central theme of the article revolves around the inverse correlation between interest rates and real estate prices. The CEO of Fundrise, Ben Miller, asserts that as interest rates decrease, real estate prices tend to rise, and conversely, as interest rates increase, real estate prices fall. This relationship is likened to gravity on a planet. Miller supports his argument by referencing the Federal Reserve's announcement of anticipated interest rate cuts, signaling a potential upswing in real estate prices.
Commercial Real Estate Market Challenges: The article highlights the challenges faced by commercial real estate investors in the current market. It mentions a slowdown in deals, growing defaults even in traditionally stable asset classes like apartments, and high borrowing costs leading to a decline in property values across the board. These challenges set the stage for Miller's perspective on the opportune moment to enter the market.
Fundrise as an Online Investing Platform: Fundrise is introduced as an online investing platform designed for non-accredited investors. It allows individuals to invest in various asset classes typically reserved for wealthier or institutional investors, such as commercial real estate, private credit, and venture capital, with a minimum investment as low as $10. The article mentions Fundrise's success, citing returns that have outperformed publicly traded REITs over several years.
Buyer's Strategy in a Changing Market: Miller advocates for a strategic approach to buying real estate in the current market conditions. He emphasizes the importance of acting when interest rates are expected to decrease, despite the challenges. The article discusses a real-world example where Fundrise lost a bid on a property in 2021 but now sees the same property back on the market at a significantly lower price due to changes in interest rates.
Risks and Challenges of the Strategy: Despite the perceived opportunity, the article highlights the risks associated with the strategy. The scarcity of willing sellers, the need to take on expensive debt leading to potential negative leverage, and the reluctance of institutional investors to approve deals with negative leverage are identified as challenges. Miller, however, believes that for those with available capital, covering short-term costs with the expectation of refinancing at a more favorable rate can be a viable strategy.
Fundrise's Investment Focus: Fundrise's investment strategy involves looking for opportunities in rental housing, including multifamily apartment towers, built-for-rent communities, and warehouses. The focus is on regions with high economic growth, such as the Sun Belt, where rent increases are prevalent, and the Southeast for warehouses due to the growing flow of consumer goods through ports.
Comparison of Housing and Investment Markets: The article draws a distinction between the typical housing market, where homes are valued based on comparable sales, and the investment market, where properties are priced based on yield. This distinction is used to explain why housing market values have remained relatively higher compared to investment values in the current market conditions.
Historical Context and Lessons: The article concludes by referencing historical market movements, particularly the 2008 Great Recession. It highlights the cyclical nature of real estate and stock prices, showcasing how prices fell during the recession and eventually rebounded. Miller suggests that investors looking at historical returns might find themselves in a similar situation, wishing they had bought during a downturn.

In summary, the article provides a comprehensive overview of the challenges and opportunities in the current U.S. commercial real estate market, framed through the lens of Fundrise's CEO, Ben Miller, and his strategic approach to navigating the evolving landscape.